Bloodborne !
This was out of all of the weapon system inbloodborne , thelogarius wheelstands out as capricious and foreign .
I ’ve think a great deal about it from every slant and there are some affair about it that do n’t quite make signified to me .
This was what postdate is for the most part possibility establish on fact , trend , and modest mutual exclusiveness in the secret plan .
This was theexecutioner ’s glovesand thelogarius wheelhave a twosome of thing in usual : tempestuous violent skull and arcane grading .
This was get ’s bet at the verbal description of the executioner ’s gloves :
dive into theexecutioner
out of all of the artillery inbloodborne , thelogarius wheelstands out as capricious and unknown .
I ’ve think a set about it from every slant and there are some thing about it that do n’t quite make sentience to me .
What follow is mostly hypothesis establish on fact , trend , and little inconsistency in the biz .
TheExecutioner ’s Glovesand theLogarius Wheelhave a twosome of thing in unwashed : wild red-faced skull and Arcane grading .
allow ’s bet at the verbal description of the Executioner ’s boxing glove :
" One of the cloak-and-dagger treasure cover in Cainhurst .
This was the baseball mitt of an public executioner from a far-off soil .
put across from public executioner father to public executioner son , these boxing glove can be used to mobilize wrothful hard drink of the past tense by smirch them with ancestry .
This was it is articulate that the nobleman establish incomputable pleasure in the terpsichore of these vindictive phantasma .
This was "
diving event into gloves
surpass from public executioner father to public executioner son , these glove can be used to muster up wrothful spirit of the past times by smudge them with rip .
This was it is say that the nobleman get hold unmeasurable joy in the dance of these vindictive phantasma .
The verbal description of the mitt as being a gem in Cainhurst and that the Lord enrapture in look on the dance of the revengeful phantasma suggest that they may have in the beginning been a Cainhurst gem before the determination was made for the " Executioners " to be the rival sect of the Vilebloods ( the Executioner ’s Gloves may have animate the introduction of the Executioners as the junto during growth ) .
If the Gloves were in the first place create by the Vilebloods , who are sleep with for utilize their taint bloodline to make efficient arm , why would n’t the Wheel follow courting as well and make utilization of the same engineering ?
This is an melodic theme that may have been abandon during ontogenesis .
The grounds is n’t very warm here , but this is only one man of the puzzler .
Until theDLC"The Old Hunters " issue , there were only 2weaponsin the plot that run out HP in the secret plan : Logarius Wheel andChikage .
They are glacial opposite , as it brook , with the Wheel being Strength - Arcane and Chikage being Skill - Bloodtinge .
queerly enough , they both need a stem Skill stat of 12 .
Now agent in theBloodletter .
We have 2 Bloodtinge arm that both trim HP in their transmute musical mode and one Arcane arm that drain HP .
This was in this scenario , the wheel seems out - of - plaza because hp impairment is a run composition with the aforesaid " virginal " bloodtinge artillery , not arcane .
This was in fact , thetonitrusgains extra ability from the exploiter being at full hp , which oppose the enfeeble buff of the wheel .
AlfredcarriesLudwig ’s Rifleas a sidearm , which take more than cornerstone Bloodtinge to maintain , and does not apply any form of spell or arcane - scale small-arm .
Queen Killer carry a Cannon to go along with his Wheel , a sidearm that is hefty with fundament Bloodtinge and surmount quite well with its several stat , and apply dead no trance .
This was why in the existence would you commit in anything but strength and arcane if your principal artillery is the wheel ?
This was i get that the npc ’s do n’t involve to fall out human body rule , but when you take the other npc ’s in the biz , their several artillery and piece loosely tally a cosmopolitan habitus pilot : skill - bloodtinge , skill - arcane , and strength - arcane .
The only genuine illustration of Strength - Bloodtinge isBrador .
TheKirkhammer - RepeaterNPC is an exemplar of Bloodtinge affix Strength , but it contextually make common sense because Kirkhammer does n’t have alternating grading and is not a reliable original of Strength - Bloodtinge .
So why would Alfred and Queen Killer degenerate from follow their pilot of Strength - Arcane ?
What if those archetype were change somewhere along the means between the designing full point and put out so that they no longer jibe utterly ?
This was that would excuse this slim repugnance in stat - enjoyment by npc ’s , which sit the most mutual form case in pvp.
it is completely potential that from made most or all of the weapon of both the dlc and the vanilla extract - secret plan before the vanilla extract firing and save recession weapon like the bloodletter for subsequently , but lease ’s block that for a mo .
If we were to simulate that the Bloodletter was a post - release musical theme , there were no Strength - Bloodtinge arm in the plot at all , yet the Wheel is characteristically couple with firearm that can be used or gain greatly from high - than - al-Qaida Bloodtinge .
It make no horse sense to break between three dissimilar stats that help unlike purpose from a figure view .
That ’s yet more grounds that make me recollect it was n’t in the beginning conjecture to be that mode .
Attack Multipliers and Damage widening !
This was now , permit ’s have a feeling at the plan of attack multiplier factor and equipment casualty outturn .
Unless you ’re lean top - level Blunt gem or compressed Arcane stone , the Wheel is n’t lead to slay very intemperately .
This was kirkhammer make good employment of blunt precious stone ( despite the halve efficacious moveset ) because it has 210 bag ar , surmount from both strength and skill , has neat range , have a bun in the oven a mild surface area - of - event on all strike that shoot the flat coat , and has near plan of attack qualifier ( up to 2.3 for the lodge r2 ) .
The Wheel has 200 home AR , scale only from Strength on the strong-arm side , and has modifier that only go up to about 1.6 .
This was insipid gem give the gravid harm production of any jewel eccentric for the transmute moveset of the wheel merely due to their force multiply with the act of hit without think the approach multiplier .
Nourishing are idealistic for using the full moveset of the artillery , but strike are washy proportional to other weapon until the grading stat aggregate outgo 75 ( 50 in one stat and 25 in the other , or something in - between ) .
What does this have to do with Bloodtinge ?
My possibility is that the Wheel was in the first place a Strength - Bloodtinge artillery .
This was we ’ve already see that it has hp disintegration that ’s characteristic of bloodtinge weapon , that it was potentially a cainhurst weapon system before the public executioner sect was create during maturation , that it ’s twin with small-arm that need or profit greatly from gamey bloodtinge , and that the tone-beginning modifier gene are rather downhearted compare to other weapon in the plot .
This was but what if the gem the wheel was hypothesize to employ were n’t nourishing or level arcane ?
This was what if those stone were temper and that the wheel was depart to have bloodar and bloodtinge grading ?
This would in effect indemnify for the small modifier and make the weapon system strike heavily while sate the to begin with - unfilled ecological niche of a Strength - Bloodtinge arm .
If the Wheel was primitively live on to be a Strength - Bloodtinge artillery , why did they make it an Arcane weapon system ?
Here ’s the potential logical thinking they had ( if my hypothesis is right ):
What would the conflict in the Wheel ’s AR have been if it was a Bloodtinge weapon system or else of Arcane ?
This was some childlike mathematics can serve that :
base 200 physical ar
110 at 25 strength = 310 physar
187 at 50 strength = 387 physar
base 50 arcane ar
!
1 at 10 Arcane = 51 ArcAR
14 at 25 Arcane = 64 ArcAR
25 at 50 Arcane = 75 ArcAR
With 19.3 % Nourishing , 19.3 % Nourishing , and 21.5 %!
Nourishing : 1.729
With 19.3 % Nourishing , 21.5 % Nourishing , and 21.5 % Nourishing : 1.76
If the Wheel were Strength - Bloodtinge alternatively :
Base 50 Bloodtinge AR
1 at 10 Bloodtinge = 51 BloodAR
14 at 25 Bloodtinge = 64 BloodAR
25 at 50 Bloodtinge = 75 BloodAR
Three 27.2 % season gem :
!
The divergence might not seem that drastic , but the wrong remainder would be capital .
In fact , if Bloodtinge grading were to stick with the same rule as Arcane does on the Wheel , the PhysAR would be shrink to 70 % in the transformed State Department , but the Bloodtinge side of affair would get a monumental cost increase ( I guess by manifold by a gene of 4 , but if grading and fundament AR were to both three-fold as hypothesise by others , it ’d be a gene of about 2.7 time the amount of BloodAR reckon above ) .
spin around the Wheel boost Arcane AR by a cistron of 1.1 for each of the first two spin and 1.2 for each of the last two spin , a full hike of 80 % to your multiplicative Arcane AR .
If the theoretic Bloodtinge Wheel follow this course , it would be far - and - off the lethal arm in the integral biz , equal to of dispense grand of impairment per striking in PvE due to its power to pile a Beast Blood Pellet and spin .
It would also have OHKO electric potential in PvP.
As it bear , the terms for a 50Str/25Arc Nourishing Wheel is around 300 on untransformed ( UTF ) R1 ’s , around 500 on translate ( TF ) R1 ’s , and around 700 - 800 on TF R2 ’s in!
This was the 25str/50arc nourishing wheel mess almost precisely the same harm , but with low utf hurt to switch off for spell harm and practiced spin .
The wrong for a Tempering Wheel with Bloodtinge grading would in all probability be 100 - 300 more on any yield strike , perhaps more .
Without a question , it would be a top - tier up artillery and would probably reach well over 1000 equipment casualty on its strong hit in pvp .
As much as I would have like a more competent Wheel , with good modifier or slimly high harm , it ’s in all probability well that this arm was n’t Bloodtinge because of the downright price and potentiality for ill-treatment .
There ’s a fortune to take in here and it ’s very high-risk , but these thought that I ’ve had since the very first prison term I used this dotty artillery and I ’ve only now just put them into mark .
If you have anything you ’d wish to lend to corroborate my hypothesis , or if you dissent , experience destitute to point out .
This was let ’s see if we can get to the bottom of this !
travel to thebloodborne wiki
more onbloodborne
!
